Colony Hotel: First a Fight, Then an Unsafe Structure Violation

Ocean Drive

Susan Askew
Susan Askew

Colony Hotel: First a Fight, Then an Unsafe Structure Violation:

Restaurant and building have a trail of violations

While fairly uneventful, one incident this Memorial Day Weekend drew some unwanted attention to Ocean Drive's Colony Hotel and its Columbus Restaurant. What the Miami Beach Crime Prevention and Awareness Group reported started as an incident inside the restaurant ended up as a street fight. In videos posted by group co-founder John Deutzman and member Mitch Novick, a large number of people can be seen running from the scene knocking others over, including Deutzman, and frightening others. 
 
Miami Beach Police Spokesman Ernesto Rodriguez said MBPD received a call that shots had been fired in the area but police found no victim or spent shell casings. “We believe that fight that was captured on video may be what triggered everyone to run,” he said. Ultimately, no report was generated and no one was arrested that he knows of.
 

Several days later, Novick was walking by and noticed severe cracking on the Hotel’s marquee over the front entrance (above). He isn't a novice at this. Back in 2004, Novick who owns the Sherbrooke Hotel, chaired Mayor David Dermer’s Blue Ribbon Panel on the Structural Integrity of Buildings. In his memo submitting the Panel’s final report, Novick wrote, “Public safety was our paramount concern when addressing the monitoring of deteriorating buildings in our City.”
 
Following Novick’s posting of the damaged structure, another crime group member notified the City and the Hotel was slapped with an unsafe structure violation by the Building Department. 
 
 

Miami Beach spokeswoman Melissa Berthier says the Hotel is allowed to continue operating but must “protect the area under the canopy to safeguard the public”, that includes removing tables under the canopy and keeping the front door locked (photo above). Access is temporarily through the side door. In addition, Berthier said, the Hotel is required to submit an engineer’s report evaluating the structure and base and to determine next actions.
 
On May 15 and 17, the City cited the Hotel for “cracked and/or broken stucco” on the front, requiring the area be “scraped and painted."
 
Naturally, everyone dug a bit further, uncovering the list of violations racked up by the Hotel and restaurant.
 
Things seem to have deteriorated since last October when the Hotel was cited for not maintaining a waste pipe and/or drain “in a good sanitary condition" following a complaint about clogged plumbing and “waste-paper contained inside the property.”
 
There have also been five sanitation violations since October including two citations for overloaded dumpsters and one for illegal disposal of bulky waste in an alleyway. The Hotel paid a fine for spilling oil in the alleyway and is currently appealing a citation from early May for raw sewage in the alleyway.  
 
The Hotel has also received three zoning violations in the past year including improper installation of speakers and TVs on the exterior of the building and one citation in January for a sign in disrepair (no further specifics are given to indicate if that sign is the same marquee that is now severely cracked).
 
The Columbus restaurant has also had three citations in the past year for illegal speaker and TV installation and one for having a DJ and speaker on New Year’s Eve without a conditional use approval.
 
As the City works to clean up Ocean Drive, you can bet there will be more attention paid to this property.
 
Top and middle photos: Mitch Novick 
Bottom photo: John Deutzman
 

More Police Officers for Ocean Drive

Ocean Drive


Susan Askew
Susan Askew
city partners with ocean drive association to put more feet on the street

Mokai and Miami Beach Reach Settlement to Allow Club to Reopen


Susan Askew
Susan Askew
Club was shutdown following video of horse inside